Traeger Banana Bread Recipe - Or Whatever You Do (2024)

This Traeger Banana Bread takes my classic sour cream banana bread and moves it to the Traeger pellet grill for a rustic, wood-kissed flavor that brings out the sweetness of the banana in the best way. This makes a big batch, so you can feed your whole family or make an extra loaf to take over to a friend or neighbor.

Traeger Banana Bread Recipe

This easy recipe has been adapted specially for your pellet grill, so whether it is the height of summer or late in the fall, if your grill is accessible and able to be fired up, you can have excellent banana bread.

My banana bread recipe has sour cream in the mix and includes a swirl of cinnamon sugar that takes the whole thing right over the top.

This is a bit batch of banana bread. A single loaf pan, even a large one, will not do. This makes enough to feed even my small army, so prepare yourself. If you have a small family and hate all your neighbors, I’d recommend halving things to make a more reasonable amount.

More Easy Traeger Recipes here!

Pellet Grill Banana Bread shopping list

• Brown bananas
• Flour
• Sugar (white & brown)
• Vanilla
• Eggs
• Canola oil
• Sour cream
• Baking soda
• Cinnamon

More great BREAKFAST RECIPES here!

How to make

This is just the overview so you can see what you’re actually getting into here. When you are cooking, you’ll want to use the full recipe at the bottom of the page.

I love this bread. It is almost cake-like, in fact, and would be perfect for a spread of cream cheese icing. We usually serve it with a pat of salted butter or the cinnamon butter below.

Banana bread is one of my favorite baked goods to make because it is SO easy, and you just throw ALL of the ingredients into a mixing bowl and mix for a couple of minutes.

There’s no sifting. No dirtying three different bowls to make sure you can mix wet ingredients, sift dry ones, and all of that stuff.

I love baking, but sometimes it is overwhelming with all the dishes and how particular you usually have to be with all of the steps. I can bake that way, but I have to be in the right mood for it.

This recipe is a snap. Just measure, put it all in one bowl, and mix it up. So simple!

Follow me on Instagram!

Join our Easy Traeger Recipes Facebook Group!

Traeger Banana Bread FAQ

What is a good spread for banana bread?

When you’ve got a warm loaf of banana bread that you’ve just pulled off the grill, now is the time to whip up a dish of this cinnamon butter.

I used 2 tablespoons of Spiceology’s Apple Cinnamon blend and mixed it with 1/2 cup of salted butter. It is a perfect mix with the sweet banana bread.

If you don’t have any of that and don’t want to wait to order it, you can mix up a little batch of cinnamon sugar butter instead. Just mix 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon with 1/2 cup of butter and 1/3 cup of honey, or to taste. You’ll find a happy medium.

Why use brown bananas?

Bananas sweeten as they ripen, as the starch turns to sugar in the fruit. However, the texture suffers once they start to become more brown than yellow. These make brown bananas the perfect addition to your baked goods. Sweet, soft, and delicious.

If you don’t have brown bananas around and are desperate for banana bread, you can go ahead and throw in your yellow bananas. I won’t tell anyone.

What kind of pans can you use to bake this banana bread?

I’ve made this bread in traditional loaf pans, 9×13 cake pans, round cake pans, bundt pans, and even in muffins and mini loaves. The pan you use will impact how long the bread takes to bake, but as long as you keep an eye on things you will be good.

Are there any recommended substitutions or additions?

As with most of my recipes, feel free to play with this one too. You can substitute equal amounts of yogurt if you don’t have sour cream. Something like Noosa or another full-fat yogurt would be best. I haven’t tried it with a fat-free Greek yogurt, so I can’t vouch there.

If you aren’t into cinnamon, you can skip that too.

Like nuts? Mix some chopped walnuts or pecans into the batter and go crazy.

Want a brulee top? Sprinkle some raw sugar over everything before you bake it.

I haven’t tested this with any gluten-free ingredients, so if that’s what you’re looking for I’d find a recipe specially designed for gluten-free flours and adapt that one for the grill instead of trying to make this recipe gluten-free.

Can you make this in an oven?

You sure can! If you don’t have a pellet grill, or just don’t feel like firing it up, you can definitely cook this in an oven.

How do you store leftover banana bread?

I always keep mine right on the counter, covered lightly with plastic wrap. It doesn’t last more than a day or so on my counter though, so I’d suggest moving it to the fridge if you think it’ll be around more than a day or two.

You can also wrap tightly in several layers of plastic wrap and then place it into a freezer bag to save it for longer in your freezer.

Once you want to eat it, put it in the fridge overnight and then reheat in your oven on low heat. (The “warm” setting is usually great for that, but you know your oven best!)

How can you tell when your banana bread is done?

Banana bread is one of the most forgiving quick breads, ever. If you overcook it by a few minutes, it’ll still be great as long as it doesn’t burn.

The best way to tell if it is done is to first check for jiggle. If you give the pan a light tap, does any part jiggle? If so – it isn’t done.

If there’s no jiggle, the next thing you need to do is to stick a wooden toothpick or small wooden skewer into the bread. It shouldn’t have any batter when it comes out with moist crumbs on it.

24 Incredible Traeger Recipes

Tips for Baking in the Traeger

A pellet grill is just a big wood-fired outdoor oven, but baking in it needs a few special considerations to keep in mind.

Use the top rack

Baked goods and casseroles have a tendency to scotch on the bottom sometimes. If you use the top rack, if you have one, it’ll create some welcome separation between the fire and your pan to help prevent that.

No top rack? No worries.

Invert a high-sided rectangular baking pan. Like this (click the image to buy):

This creates enough separation to prevent burning in most cases. I keep a closer eye on things using this method than I do when I use the top rack, so you’re aware.

It is a good idea to place the pans in the areas that are NOT directly above the fire pot, to be on the safe side.

Try our Blueberry Muffins too!

Love banana? Try this Banana Crumb Cake!

Get all of my easy dessert recipes here!